( Six minute read)
What does “before” and “after” even mean?
When you ask what existed before time began, you are using a word that presupposes time in the first place. You are looking at the moment when the clock on the wall, and the very idea of “earlier” and “later” all emerge together.
Take “Before” it describes a relationship between two moments, one earlier and one later, and if there is no timeline at all, that relationship cannot be defined.
You are basically asking what color is beyond the edge of the color spectrum, or what lies one step past the last number. Your intuition wants an answer, but your current physical theories are not built to even frame that as a well-posed problem.
As strange as this questions sound, modern physics, from relativity to quantum theory, keeps nudging us toward answers that feel more like science fiction than everyday life, time binds us to a simple rule:
Cause always precedes effect.
Time is baked into how you write almost every law in physics, whether as a time derivative, a sequence of states, or a cause leading to an effect.
Without time, those terms evaporate, and your mathematical language suddenly has no verbs, only nouns.
If time moves forward like dominoes falling, every thought, emotion, and choice you make right now is the inevitable result of prior physical states (your brain’s neurochemistry, upbringing, evolutionary biology, and the state of the universe a millisecond ago).
You feel like you’re steering, but you’re actually riding a track laid down by the past.
For a choice to matter, your intention must cause a future action.
As long as your decisions stem from your own internal beliefs and desires—without outside force—you have genuine free will, even if those desires were shaped by past events.
In Einstein’s General Relativity, space and time are fused into a four-dimensional “block universe.”
Past, present, and future all coexist statically.
Your entire life is a frozen movie reel.
You aren’t “writing” the future as time marches forward; you’re simply experiencing the reel unwinding frame by frame.
At the micro level, quantum mechanics suggests the future isn’t strictly determined—outcomes are probabilistic.
However, replacing determinism with fundamental randomness doesn’t automatically grant agency; doing something randomly is very different from choosing it intentionally.
The one-way flow of time means you can never undo a choice, but whether that choice was truly “yours” depends on whether you define free will as absolute independence from the past or the ability to act according to your own mind.
Imagine waking up tomorrow and realizing that every moment of your life is happening at once.
I think , therefore I am.
It encapsulates the prevailing view of what it means to be human:
So feeling came first.
Every second, the brain is flooded with sights, sounds, smells, and signals from inside the body.
Yet only a fraction of this information reaches our conscious awareness, thanks to neural systems that filter out what is familiar or unimportant.
Happiness serves a purpose. “It’s telling you, ‘you have license to enjoy life,’”
The very concept of “before” may simply not exist when you go back far enough.
Time, according to the best models you have today, is not an endless line stretching forever into the past. It had a beginning.
When talking about the big bang you are not just talking about matter expanding into space; you are talking about space and time themselves stretching and coming into existence as the universe evolves.
Time is baked into how you write almost every law in physics, whether as a time derivative, a sequence of states, or a cause leading to an effect.
Without time, those terms evaporate, and your mathematical language suddenly has no verbs, only nouns.
So when you ask what existed before time began, you are using a word that presupposes time in the first place.
“Before” describes a relationship between two moments, one earlier and one later, and if there is no timeline at all, that relationship cannot be defined.
You are basically asking what color is beyond the edge of the color spectrum, or what lies one step past the last number.
Your intuition wants an answer, but your current physical theories are not built to even frame that as a well-posed problem.
All human comments appreciated. All like clicks and abuse chucked in the bin.
Contact; bobdillon33@gmail.com
